Filmmaker Charlie Lyne follows up his debut feature Beyond Clueless with another cinematic essay, which this time focuses on the horror genre. Built around its narration by actress Amy E Watson, Fear Itself consists entirely of clips from various horror films. While there are some familiar titles featured, such as Psycho and The Exorcist, there seems to be a heavy focus on obscure or foreign horror films, which would be practically unknown to all but the most devout fan of the genre. As the clips play, the narration talks about how horror films seem to know how to scare you, with you not knowing when fear is going to come.
Even though I was not a fan of Beyond Clueless, I had some high hopes for Fear Itself and I actually believed that the film started off strong, with the documentary being appropriately atmospheric. However, the film started to lose me when it started showing clips from decidedly non horror films, such as Gravity, Elephant, and Alive. This seems to suggest that there wasn't really a clear sense of direction for the film, with Fear Itself's thesis involving the human need for fear being vague at best. I would actually recommended seeking out the more balanced 2014 documentary Why Horror? and staying clear of Fear Itself.